Donate to Preservation Chicago on Giving Tuesday!

WIN: Landmark Commission Rejects Demolition Permit Application for Historic Former Fiat Dealership/E2 Nightclub Building on Motor Row Landmark at 2357 S. Michigan

Former Fiat Dealership/E2 Nightclub Building, 2357 S. Michigan. Tweet credit: Chicago DPD
Former Fiat Dealership/E2 Nightclub Building, 2357 S. Michigan. Photo credit: VHT Studios
Ward Miller of Preservation Chicago interview regarding the “Future of E2 nightclub building in limbo after 2003 tragedy.” Image credit FOX 32 Chicago

“Chicago’s Commission on Landmarks has denied a permit application to demolish the building on South Michigan Avenue, located in the city’s historic Motor Row District. …families of the victims feel that a permanent monument or memorial for their loved ones is long overdue.

“The Richard H. Driehaus Executive Director of Preservation Chicago, Ward Miller, says the building offers a significant contribution to one of the largest, intact 20th century automobile rows in existence. He adds that he hopes to see all parties come to a resolution.

“‘We do believe that we should collectively all work together to come to some sort of resolution, as to how we demarcate this terrible tragedy, so that this never happens again,’ said Ward. ‘But if we demolish the building, we not only lose a component of this Motor Row District—that’s the best of the best in the nation—but we also lose a touchstone to this really terrible tragedy.’ (Chronis, FOX 32 Chicago, 11/7/24)

“Before a final vote on the demolition permit on Thursday, Howard Ray, whose brother was killed in the stampede, talked about what he wanted.

“‘The current E2 family proposals include a community benefit agreement, a memorial, and historical landmark designation. We believe these proposals align with the Chicago broader commitment to acknowledging its complex history, and honoring its diverse community,’ he said. (Feurer, CBS News Chicago, 11/7/24)

“‘This is one of the most intact districts of these motor row showrooms in the nation,’ said Ward Miller, executive director of Preservation Chicago.

“The building, located at 2347 S. Michigan Ave., was completed in 1910 and originally housed a Fiat showroom.

“In order to make changes to the former nightclub, Miller explained the building’s current owner needs approval from the Commission on Chicago Landmarks. He added that he feels finding a way to honor the victims while also encouraging a rebirth of the current building would be beneficial to historic preservation.

“My heart and our hearts go out to the people that were lost there,” said Miller. “And development, in this case-sensitive development, is a reinvestment in these structures.”

“‘It’s been unoccupied for 21 years, so it just doesn’t make sense to keep it here, but the families, a lot of the family members want it here,’ said Takala Welch, a local activist. ‘It’s still something for them to kind of hold onto because it’s the last piece of them.’

“When the owner applied for a permit to demolish the site, however, it was denied by the Commission on Chicago Landmarks—which cited historical significance tied to the 20th-century automobile industry—leaving the future of the building at a standstill.” (Chronis, FOX 32 Chicago, 10/17/24)

“Among those opposed to demolishing the structure were representatives from Preservation Chicago, members of the Near South Planning Board and Ald. Pat Dowell (3rd), who reaffirmed her commitment to establish an on-site memorial while asking the commission to uphold the Department of Planning’s previous findings.” (Nesbitt Golden, Block Club Chicago, 10/18/24)

“‘It is a textbook example of a contributing building within the landmark district to Chicago’s Motor Row and automotive history,’ said Patrick Grossi of Preservation Chicago.” (Schulte, ABC 7 Chicago, 10/17/24)

Watch the full story at FOX 32 Chicago and read the full story at Block Club Chicago

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

88 − = 82

Captcha verification failed!
CAPTCHA user score failed. Please contact us!