CHICAGO LEGACY BUSINESS: Goose Island Shrimp House Celebrates 53 Years on Division Street

Goose Island Shrimp House, 1011 W. Division St., Chicago. A Chicago Legacy Business since 1973. Photo credit: Google Map

Goose Island Shrimp House, 1011 W. Division St., Chicago. A Chicago Legacy Business since 1973. Photo credit: Google Maps

“Over the past three decades, the West Side native has risen the ranks from night shift worker to manager to owner of Goose Island Shrimp House, the no-frills, counter-service-only spot that’s offered a simple menu of fried shrimp, frog legs and other seafood since 1973.

“Eichelberger has served thousands of Chicagoans over the years, including many families who grew up nearby in Cabrini Green and still return to the shrimp house at 1011 W. Division St., even if they now live miles away.

“Then there’s the longtime staff members, some of whom — like Eichelberger’s brother and general manager, Bernard — have also worked at the restaurant about as long as he has.

“‘We’re not just a little restaurant. We’re part of a big community. We’re a family. We’re the Goose Island family, you know,’ Eichelberger, 53, said. ‘There’s something more to this than just working at a restaurant.’

“The restaurant next week will be given the annual Small Business of the Year Award from North Branch Works, an economic development organization that represents businesses in the area.

“Eichelberger told Shaw he was interested and went to work for the restaurant’s original owner Ed Polizzi, who launched the shrimp house in 1973.

“‘We were all nationalities at work here. He was Italian, but he loved each and every one of us,’ said Eichelberger, who took over the restaurant more than a decade ago. ‘My brother would get a job, my best friend’s brother would get a job. … It was all family, always family-oriented. He wanted to have that family-type legacy for this place.’

“That bond extended to the shrimp shack’s customers over the years, many of whom lived just east in the Cabrini Green housing projects.

“Eichelberger said the restaurant’s ties to Cabrini remain a major part of its legacy. Neighbors who had to move after most of the housing project was demolished in the 2000s still make it a point to return to the neighborhood to pick up their favorite order from Goose Island.

“‘I’ve seen grandparents, kids, grandkids, great grandkids — they all come back, even though they’re gone. They come back, and we remember each other. It’s like a celebration. When they come in, we know them, they know us,’ he said. ‘It’s a part of their history as well as a part of Chicago’s.’

“Something unique about Goose Island Shrimp House is that its menu never changes.

“‘If you want a burger, you gotta go to Burger King or McDonald’s. You want chicken, you gotta go to Popeyes,’ he said. ‘People always ask, “Why don’t you sell chicken?” Because we’re a shrimp house. We specialize in shrimp, so this is what we have.’

“While many of Goose Island’s customers are neighbors or people who work nearby, the restaurant has also attracted its fair share of celebrity visitors over the years, many of whom can be seen in photos behind the counter. That includes Steve Harvey, Shaquille O’Neal, Jack Black and the actress LisaRaye. Scottie Pippen also used to come in when he was playing with the Bulls, Bernard Eichelberger said.

“Then there’s the Thanksgiving meal giveaway, which last year fed 100 families. Eichelberger said he wants to double that number this year, hopefully with the help of local companies and corporations.

“‘I may not be here in 50 years,’ he said, but ‘I want to do more, and if I do more for the community, then there has to be a Goose Island in 50 years.’” (Myers, Block Club Chicago, 10/1/26)

“Chicago Legacy Businesses are unique, authentic, precious assets. They are also endangered.

“Pressure from rising rents and competition from national chains has forced many Chicago Legacy Businesses to close. Chicago Legacy Businesses have supported Chicago for decades. They have anchored neighborhoods, provided jobs, and delighted generations of Chicagoans and tourists. Chicago Legacy Businesses are a reflection of Chicago which is culturally rich and racially diverse. Their authenticity and uniqueness contribute to the quality of life for Chicagoans.

“Chicago Legacy Businesses are typically multi-generational, family-owned, locally-operated, customer-facing businesses in operation for over 35 years. Business owners often live in their community and employ people from their community.

“Too often, the first media attention happens following the announcement that they are closing. The more publicity and attention they are given, the more likely Chicagoans and tourists are to patronize these businesses.” (Preservation Chicago, The Case to Support Chicago Legacy Businesses)

Preservation Chicago congratulates Lamon Eichelberger, Bernard Eichelberger and the staff of Goose Island Shrimp House on 53 years of tasty business, and applauds North Branch Works for recognizing them. We encourage Chicagoans to support Chicago Legacy Businesses and we continue urging the City of Chicago to establish a formal Chicago Legacy Business program that creates policy that would help Chicago Legacy Businesses remain vibrant for the next generation.

Read the full story at Block Club Chicago

Goose Island Shrimp Honored After 53 Years As A Chicago Staple; The Division Street institution has been serving up fried shrimp since 1973. The restaurant will receive a local small business award next week for its contributions to the neighborhood, Quinn Myers, Block Club Chicago, 10/1/26

Honor Local Businesses at Fall Fest; North Branch Works

The Case to Support Chicago Legacy Businesses; Preservation Chicago

Help Celebrate and Protect Chicago’s Historic Buildings.

Preservation Chicago is supported by people who love the city as much as we do. Join us!

Donate

Preservation Chicago is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit. All donations are fully tax-deductible as permitted by law.

Stay in the Loop

Get monthly updates on advocacy efforts in neighborhoods all across Chicago.

Preservation Chicago: Love Your City Fiercely!®